Every AirPods Pro owner eventually faces the same small problem. The original silicone tips wear out, get lost, or simply never fit quite right, and Apple charges a premium for a tiny piece of rubber. The aftermarket has answered with a flood of cheap replacements, but most of them fail at the one thing that matters: holding a seal tight enough for the noise cancellation to do its job. This set of three pairs of replacement ear tips for AirPods Pro 1st and 2nd generation promises a proper fit, a noise reduction hole, and a portable storage box, all at a fraction of the Apple price. I put them through weeks of daily use to see whether they measure up.
Before the tips, the standard note: this article contains affiliate links. If you buy through any of them, this site earns a small commission at no extra cost to you, and it does not affect what I test or what I recommend.
Design and Build
The set arrives with three pairs of tips in the standard sizes: small, medium, and large, all in white to match the Apple aesthetic. Each tip is molded silicone with the familiar oval opening at the top that fits the AirPods Pro stem, and the shape mirrors the original design closely enough that the difference is almost invisible at a glance. A small vent hole sits on the side of each tip, which is the noise reduction hole that helps equalize pressure in the ear.
The silicone itself is the first thing you notice. It is soft and slightly tacky, which is exactly the feel that makes a tip grip the ear canal without sliding out. Cheaper tips use a harder compound that pops out of place, but this material has the right balance of give and hold. Each tip snaps onto the earbud with a firm click and sits flush, and they come off cleanly for a swap without tearing the silicone.
The included storage box is a genuinely useful addition. It is a small white case with a clear lid that holds all three pairs, so the spares stay organized instead of rolling around in a drawer. It is not as compact as the AirPods case itself, but it fits neatly in a tech pouch or desk drawer, and it keeps the tips clean between uses.
Key Features
The headline feature is the noise reduction hole. On the Apple originals, a similar vent lets air escape so the earbud does not build pressure in the ear canal. On these replacements the vent serves the same purpose: it keeps the tip from feeling like a plug while preserving the acoustic seal. In practice that means the active noise cancellation still has a sealed chamber to work against, which is the difference between effective silence and a leaky hiss.
The three size option is the practical feature most buyers will appreciate. Ear canals vary enough that the medium that works for one person will leak on another, and having small, medium, and large in the box means you can find the seal that actually blocks sound. The tips also fit both the 1st and 2nd generation AirPods Pro, which broadens the compatibility beyond the older model.
Case compatibility is the subtle detail that many aftermarket sets get wrong. Some replacement tips are too tall, which prevents the AirPods Pro case from closing or forces the Earbuds to charge at an angle. These tips are sized to the original profile, and in my testing the case closed fully with a firm click and the earbuds charged normally, no fiddling required.
Real-World Performance
I started with the medium tips, the default for my ears, and the seal was immediately better than the worn originals I had been using. The difference showed up in the noise cancellation test. With music paused on a busy street, the low rumble of traffic dropped to a distant murmur, which told me the tips were sealing properly. The vent did its job too, the ear felt no uncomfortable pressure even after a long session.
Comfort held up over hours of wear. The soft silicone did not irritate the ear canal, and the medium size stayed put through a walk, a workout, and a long call. The true test came when I tried the large size, which I normally find too big. Even then the tacky silicone grabbed the canal without the pressure pinch that hard plastic tips cause, and the sound stayed balanced rather than muffled.
The storage box proved its worth on a trip. I packed two pairs in the box and left the third on the earbuds, and everything stayed organized. The tips also cleaned up well under warm water after a sweaty session, and they dried without warping, which is a common failure point for budget silicone.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fits both AirPods Pro 1st and 2nd generation
- Noise reduction hole preserves the ANC seal
- Soft, tacky silicone holds its position all day
- Charging case closes fully with tips installed
- Three sizes plus a handy storage box
Cons:
- Silicone still needs regular cleaning to stay fresh
- White finish picks up lint and dust over time
- Storage box adds bulk beyond the earbud case
- Largest size may still not suit very wide ear canals
How It Compares
Set against Apple's own replacement tips, the differences come down to price and packaging. Apple sells a single set of its foam-tipped alternative at a much higher cost, while this set gives you three pairs of silicone for a fraction of that price. For the vast majority of users the silicone material works identically for fit and ANC, and the three sizes cover more ear shapes.
| Feature | This 3 Pair Set | Apple Replacement Tips |
|---|---|---|
| Quantity | 3 pairs | 1 pair |
| Material | Soft silicone | Silicone or foam |
| Price | Much lower | Premium |
| Storage box | Included | Not included |
| ANC seal | Effective | Effective |
Compared to generic no name tips from the bargain shelf, these are a clear step up. The generic versions often use a harder silicone that slides out, skip the vent hole, or make the case bulge. This set gets the three details right: material, vent, and case fit. If your original tips are worn or lost, this is the value pick that does not compromise the listening experience. You can check the current price at these AirPods Pro ear tips on Amazon.
Who Should Buy It
Buy these if you own AirPods Pro and your original tips are worn, lost, or just never sealed properly. They suit the commuter who needs noise cancellation to actually block the train, the runner who keeps losing the right size, and anyone who wants a spare set without paying Apple's price. The three sizes make them a good choice for a household where two people share a pair of earbuds.
Skip them if you already have a set of foam tips you love, or if your ear canals are so unusual that only the foam memory material will hold. For the standard AirPods Pro owner, though, this is the replacement set that does everything the originals do for a fraction of the cost.
How We Test
I tested these ear tips over two weeks with AirPods Pro 1st and 2nd generation. I verified the case fit, measured the ANC seal against background noise, wore each size for multi hour sessions, and ran the tips through washing to confirm they held their shape. I also compared them directly with the original Apple tips on the same earbuds.
Ear tip fit and noise cancellation guidance is well covered at Wirecutter, and the basics apply here: a good seal is everything. These tips deliver that seal at a price that makes replacement painless, and they earn a clear recommendation. Check the live listing at the replacement ear tips for AirPods Pro.
Questions People Ask
Do these ear tips fit AirPods Pro 2nd generation?
Yes. They are compatible with both the 1st and 2nd generation AirPods Pro, and they fit securely in the charging case with the lid closed. I tested both generations without any issue.
Will the replacement tips stay in the charging case?
Yes. The tips sit snugly on the earbuds and the case closes fully, so the earbuds charge normally and the tips do not pop off when you open the lid.
Does the noise reduction hole change the sound?
The small vent in the tip helps equalize pressure and keeps the seal intact, so active noise cancellation keeps working as intended. The sound stays balanced with a proper fit in the ear.
Are these ear tips comfortable for long wear?
The silicone is soft and the three sizes let you find a snug seal. In testing they stayed comfortable through multi hour listening sessions without irritation or pressure points.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
